Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Excuses, Excuses

Image fron US Department of Transportation, June 2026.


Kurt Andersen caught a funny locution in Trump's account of Jensen Huang's honeytrap, if that's what it was:

Trump learned a year ago that his pal Jensen Huang was having an affair with a Chinese spy—just as he and Huang made a deal to let Nvidia sell advanced AI chips to China. His comment about it now is such quintessential Trump : "I think he probably has an excuse for it.” Not explanation—“excuse.”

Which made me think of Wallace Stevens:

This Is Just to Say

I have sold
the chips
that President Xi
was admiring

and which you
were probably
planning to use
for America

Forgive me
they were so cute
and my girlfriend
was so hot
***

I'll get back to that. First, I want to talk about something else: Air Space Intelligence, or ASI, a Boston-based software company (moved from Silicon Valley in 2024) that uses artificial intelligence to plan air traffic management, the kind of thing AI is at least notionally extremely good at (putting together huge amounts of data on hugely complex systems—airline schedules, airport capacities, weather, and wind—and predicting how they will all interact), and apparently pretty good at it, judging from reports on  Flyways, the dispatchers' tool it built for Alaska Airlines, which has been using it since 2021, saving a lot of time and money in flight hours and fuel. Delta and United use the company's products too, as well as the US Army and Air Force. Last June it got a couple of no-bid contracts adding up to almost a billion dollars with the Federal Aviation Administration ($875 million over 12 years, to be exact), for two products: Flow Management Data and Services (FMDS) meant to replace the FAA's traffic management system, and Strategic Management of Airspace, Routes, and Trajectories (SMART), which was the AI part, and which the company started testing in the Washington, DC area in September and extended to the entire nation's 22 air route traffic control centers on (checks notes) Tuesday, three days before communication problems sent the whole system into a rare ground stop on air flights in the US that lasted five hours and snarled up a lot of lives. 

It's also said to be one of those companies negotiating a deal to sell shares to the government—the only one doing it with FAA—with a CEO founder, Phillip Buckendorf, who has praised the Trump administration's AI policy at a Breitbart News event in DC a couple of months ago, with a PAC that has donated recently to some eight Republican politicians, mostly serving in Congress on relevant committees, but including $2,500 last March, three months before the contract was signed, for Michael Alfonso, a 26-year old novice running in Wisconsin's 6th congressional district (he won last week), who is Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy's son-in-law. Well well well. None of the donations are exactly big.

I don't have any reason to think ASI's engineers are anything short of great at their jobs (but Buckendorf isn't an engineer; he's an immigrant entrepreneur from Germany, with a German BA in international relations, focusing on China). I do have reason to think the project may have been rushed somewhat, because that's what 25 Democratic congressmembers under the leadership of Rep. Apirl McLain Delaney said in a letter of October 9:

“Last month, the Federal Aviation Administration surprisingly launched an AI tool to help control air traffic over three major National Capital Region Airports, with plans to expand nationwide in the following 90 days. They did so without publishing a safety evaluation or sufficiently consulting air traffic controllers and safety experts. We are urging Transportation Secretary Duffy and FAA Administrator Bedford to stop the rollout until we have answers. This administration may treat Big Tech companies with impunity, but air traffic control leaves zero margin for error,” said Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. 

The FAA’s rush to deploy a system that could affect the lives of millions of Americans is especially concerning for residents of this region, who are still grappling with questions about air safety following last year’s fatal crash at DCA. Before deploying its AI-enabled SMART air traffic control tool, the FAA must demonstrate, through air traffic controller feedback and independently verified testing, that this technology is safe and reliable, and it must clearly communicate those findings to the public,” Congressman Don Beyer. 

"Families across Baltimore count on BWI to get them where they’re going safely. Yet the Trump Administration recklessly rolled out an untested AI air traffic tool there without publishing a safety evaluation or adequately consulting the air traffic controllers who keep us safe. There is no room for error in our skies. I am proud to co-lead this letter calling for public transparency and answers from Secretary Duffy and Administrator Bedford on how this system was tested, who was consulted, and how it will be evaluated. Until they provide answers that ensure that this technology is safe, the FAA must pause its use," said Congressman Kweisi Mfume.

But FAA failed to respond to the letter by the October 19 deadline—they just didn't bother, as far as I can tell—and they implemented the plan on schedule, and by now everybody knows what happened after that. That is, nobody got killed, only hugely inconvenienced, and the SMART project was clearly a failure, though nobody's willing to say that. I mean, if "the new technology was overloading the old" as Duffy and Mullins said, it was their job to be ready to prevent that; to figure out how to compensate for it or insist on more time to figure it out. If they couldn't fix the old equipment they should have replaced it. It should have been clear that the machine wasn't ready to work on the national scale without signigficant changes. 

We've been assured in Duffy's Saturday press conference that SMART had nothing to do with Friday's crisis, which is said to have been caused by some fault in the FAA's ongoing project to replace all the copper wiring in the the communications system with a fiber optics system, either in El Dorado, Arkansas or Amarillo, Texas. SMART could not be responsible for anything that happened on Friday:

the FAA has stressed that SMART "cannot be used to replace the critical role air traffic controllers play or take over control of an aircraft." By the FAA's description, the tool generates advisory routing information that flows through existing systems and procedures.

It does not assume day-to-day control operations, and it does not act on its own.

Though I don't see why something it prepared for Friday on Wednesday or Thursday couldn't have gone wrong in response to the thing that happened on Friday to trigger whatever it was. And then it could have been something else, because there's a big flaw in the fiber-optic story being set on a busy Friday afternoon:

Washington Examiner national security reporter Anna Giaritelli told CNN‘s Laura Coates that she had spoken with 60 air traffic controllers, and none supported Duffy’s account. 

“None of them are buying what he said,” she reported.... such technology upgrades are normally performed during quieter periods, particularly in the middle of the night when air traffic is minimal.

Nor is it normal, as Lucian Truscott notes, for an enormous technological system like this to be so short of built-in redundancy that a failure in a single router in Arkansas can lead the outage of the entire thing.  

The fiber-optic conversion has been going on for quite a while—FAA claims that it's 70% done—and has never caused anything like this. The only comparable case since 9/11/2001 (which was really exceptional) was in January 2023, when some files in a critical database, NOTAM (Notice to Air Missions) were accidentally deleted, exactly the kind of thing that could have gone wrong with SMART (which uses the 200 different data streams integrated by FMDS to schedule flights) in its first to-scale deployment last week. (Gemini reports that FMDS and SMART have not been turned off, but the sources it cites don't actually say that). 

This is coherent with remarks by Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin on Monday suggesting that the incident was caused by "SI" (not Staten Island, but "superintelligence", the president's new name for artificial intelligence, a term he dislikes because it make the thing sound unnatural, like artificial flowers, I don't know if he thinks AI is grown in a greenhouse or what):

“I started talking to the tech industry,” Mullin told Fox News on Monday, adding he talked to a person in tech that thought “that it’s the SI, he said, because these programs aren’t designed to work as fast as SI is.”

“When they put in a program that’s able to write codes and it goes in, it self-fixes itself,” Mullin continued. “It’s like doing a change order on a house. When you change one thing in a house, everything else starts changing, that’s a ripple effect. And it causes a system to be overran that weren’t designed to run as fast as the SI technology is today.”

Snobs make fun of Mullin because he ran a plumbing business before he went into politics, but I think politics could use more homely metaphors drawn from real life. Duffy and Trump have flashier backgrounds, with their reality-TV experience, but how often do they come up with an idea this sensible? 

I'm suggesting, like Truscott, that the story Duffy told on Saturday is starting to look like a lie, I mean concocted, as if to cover up something between an embarrassment and a catastrophe, and I really can't begin to speculate which or how, I know nothing about these technologies, beyond the praise that rightfully belongs to the work force of human air traffic controllers and even more the maintenance mechanics, systems specialists, and technical support workers who have been decimated since the Reagan administration, who took us through this crisis landing thousands of flights with no crashes or injuries. Lots of more valuable info on the tech aspects and Duffy's and Mullins's changing stories is available from Jay Kuo.

***

All I have to say about Jensen Huang for now is that whether or not he was aware that one of his girlfriends (two others were executives at Nvidia, over whom he had hiring and firing authority, which is why his board had to fire him, if you wanted to know) was or may have been connected to Chinese intelligence services, which Trump seems to think is the central question—

“I asked him that question: ‘Did you have any idea that she was a spy?’” Mr. Trump told reporters at the White House. “He said, ‘I had no idea that she was a spy,’ and I really believe him.”

—really isn't. 

The biggest question would be whether Huang is working for them himself, not to mention commerce secretary Howard Lutnick and the US president, given the effort all of them have made (using the rundown by Heather Cox Richardson) to get around the 2022 (Biden administration) prohibition against selling Nvidia's most advanced AI chips to China by renting them to China instead, through data centers in Malaysia, Thailand, and Indonesia that had acquired them, through the Singapore firm Megaspeed, which was where the girlfriend-spy Alice Huang (no relation to Jensen other than the, you know, sexual, it's a common name) worked. Lutnick's former firm Cantor Fitzgerald, now run by his sons, is apparently a big investor in the Southeast Asian data centers, and Trump, owned $62 million or more in Nvidia stock, at least until the collapse of the price that began in early October), so there was plenty of money in it for all of them, and you'd think that would be a sufficient "excuse" for the scheme; evading the law for a profit is these guys' favorite occupation. 

But it would also be the case that the biggest beneficiary of the scheme would be the People's Republic, said to need advanced technology from the US (i.e. Nvidia) in its work to "win" the world competition in the field, and the best positioned, as a state actor with all the resources of its intelligence system (which I'm afraid the US isn't at the moment, with the Trump cabinet gutting the intelligence community), to plot such as scheme, and Trump's irrepressible personal crush on General Secretary Xi Jinping has international consequences (for instance, something over $15 billion of military aid to Taiwan approved by Congress in January 2025 is under a still unexplained hold). So why wouldn't they?

Speaking of plums, Little Jack Horner, uncredited via Short Kid Stories.


No comments:

Post a Comment